Four Reasons Why Refinishing is Better than Lining a Tub

When considering bathroom renovation ideas, many homeowners discover that there's more than one way to revamp their tub beyond simply refinishing. Custom bathtub liners are often promoted as a great alternative for those dealing with damaged or outdated bathtubs. These liners are essentially molded acrylic inserts designed to fit perfectly over your existing tub, providing a complete coverage solution. While there may be specific instances where a liner is the ideal option, here are four compelling reasons why refinishing is generally the superior choice.

Price Tag

To start with, refinishing is typically much more budget-friendly. The cost of refinishing mainly covers the materials used and the time spent by the professional doing the work. On the flip side, installing a liner requires specialized measurements, which means hiring someone to visit your home to assess your tub. Then, there’s the manufacturing phase, followed by shipping, and finally, the installation itself. All these steps can significantly drive up the price compared to refinishing, which remains relatively straightforward and cost-effective.

Convenience Factor

Opting for a liner might sound appealing, but it comes with its own set of inconveniences. First, you’ll need to book an appointment for a technician to measure and photograph your tub. After that, you’ll have to wait while the liner is made, which can take several weeks. Once ready, you’ll need yet another appointment to install it. Altogether, this process could take anywhere from two to six weeks. In contrast, refinishing your tub is far more efficient. Once you pick a color, you only need to arrange one full day for the professional to complete the job. Although refinishing involves some initial mess, a skilled installer will ensure your bathroom remains safe and well-ventilated during the process. With a curing period of 24-48 hours, your newly refinished tub will be ready to use sooner than you think.

Comfort and Functionality

Custom bathtub liners aim for a perfect fit, but the outcome can vary depending on the contractor and manufacturer. Poor installation or a misfit can make the liner feel hollow or spongy, which is not ideal. Additionally, liners tend to reduce the interior space of your tub slightly. For those with smaller tubs, this change could pose a challenge. Refinishing, however, doesn't add any extra bulk. The new surface is applied directly onto your existing tub, ensuring a seamless and accurate fit. Whether you have a modestly sized tub or a unique vintage piece, refinishing preserves all its original charm without hiding it beneath a layer of acrylic.

Potential Risks

At first glance, liners may appear sturdier, but they carry certain risks that refinishing avoids. Cheaper, thinner liners are prone to cracking, allowing water to seep through and potentially leading to mold and mildew issues. Even high-quality liners could develop leaks if improperly installed or if they shift over time, causing the caulking to wear away. Once water gets trapped between the liner and the original tub, it can create a breeding ground for mold and mildew, eventually necessitating a full tub replacement. With refinished tubs, the primary concern is scratches that could expose the original surface underneath. This issue is easily mitigated by using gentle, non-abrasive cleaning products, ensuring your refinished tub stays in excellent condition for years to come.

Why Choose Refinishing with Maryland Tub and Tile?

If you're interested in learning more about refinishing your bathtub, reach out to Maryland Tub and Tile. Our team can walk you through the refinishing process, highlighting additional benefits such as the wide range of colors available. We also offer free estimates and can help determine if refinishing is the best solution for your bathroom renovation needs. Let us show you how refinishing can breathe new life into your bathroom while saving you both time and money.