Four Reasons Why Refinishing is Better than Lining a Tub

When considering bathroom renovation ideas, you’ve probably noticed that there’s more than one way to refresh your bathtub. While refinishing is a popular choice, custom bathtub liners are also gaining traction as a solution for older or damaged tubs. These liners are essentially acrylic inserts crafted to fit snugly over your existing tub, offering a new surface without replacing the entire unit. Although there may be specific instances where a liner makes sense, here are four compelling reasons why refinishing is generally the superior option.

Price Tag

To start with, refinishing is almost always the more budget-friendly choice. The cost primarily involves the materials needed and the time invested by the professional doing the work. Conversely, custom liners require tailored manufacturing, which adds significant expenses. First, a technician must visit your home to measure and photograph your tub, followed by production time and shipping. Installation itself requires yet another appointment. Altogether, this can stretch from two to six weeks and end up costing much more than refinishing.

Convenience Factor

Opting for a liner means preparing for a lengthy process. You’ll need to set aside time for multiple visits—first for measurements, then for installation after the liner arrives. This timeline can be inconvenient, especially if you're eager to get your bathroom back to normal. On the flip side, refinishing is a simpler process that typically requires just one day for completion. While the refinishing process can be messy during application, professionals take great care to ensure your bathroom remains safe and well-ventilated. After a couple of days of curing, you’ll have a refreshed bathtub ready for use.

Comfort and Functionality

Custom liners are designed to match your tub precisely, but achieving the perfect fit depends heavily on both the contractor and the manufacturer. If the fit isn’t ideal, the liner might feel hollow or spongy. Additionally, these liners tend to reduce the tub's interior space slightly, which could pose issues if your tub is already compact. Refinishing, however, preserves the original tub’s dimensions without adding bulk. Whether you have an antique tub or a modest-sized one, refinishing ensures its unique features remain intact, giving you a fresh look without sacrificing usability.

Potential Risks

At first glance, liners might appear more durable, but they carry certain risks that refinishing avoids. Cheaper liners are prone to cracking, potentially leading to water seepage beneath the surface. Even high-quality liners can develop leaks if improperly installed or if shifting occurs over time. Once water penetrates the gap between the liner and the original tub, mold and mildew can flourish, eventually necessitating a complete tub replacement. Refinished surfaces face minimal risks, though scratches are possible. However, this issue can be easily managed by avoiding harsh cleaning agents; gentle products will keep your refinished surface looking great for years.

Why Choose Refinishing with Maryland Tub and Tile?

If you’re curious about refinishing your bathtub, reach out to us at Maryland Tub and Tile. We’ll explain our process in detail, highlighting additional benefits such as the vast range of color options available. Requesting a free estimate is easy, and we’ll help determine whether refinishing aligns with your renovation goals. Whether you want to preserve the charm of an old tub or give your bathroom a modern twist, refinishing could be the ideal solution for you.